/crypto-fans-should-get-behind-elon-musk-s-subscription-model-for-twitter
Crypto fans should get behind Elon Musk’s subscription model for Twitter

post

Like many people, I was originally dubious of Elon Musk’s takeover of Twitter given his historic tendency to make bold promises but later back away. That said, there is merit to his idea of adding a subscription layer to Twitter and using it to both improve curation and diversify away from advertising. If you believe in the core values of crypto, you should believe in it.

To see why, we need to revisit the basics of Bitcoin (BTC). Most people focus their attention on the coin, but the more remarkable thing about Satoshi Nakamoto’s invention was the design of the platform.

Before Bitcoin, the general belief was that an open (aka permissionless) system where participants are anonymous and free to come and go could never be secured. Solutions like Byzantine fault tolerance — the network equivalent of democracy — had solved the problem of participants reaching consensus in a closed system, but couldn’t be applied to an open network due to the risk of one participant pretending to be many, also known as a Sybil attack.

Sybil attacks are a threat to any democratic system, thus the need for restrictions like voter registration or parliamentary roll call. They are particularly pesky online, where one person pretending to be many people is easy. Thus the prevalence of spam email, fake reviews and bot armies on the internet.

Social media as designed today solves this problem in the same way that payment systems (like PayPal) did in the past: They put an authority in charge and give it the power to censor some users to protect others. But this approach had its own drawbacks, including some people being censored unfairly and the authority extracting significant value for itself. Twitter’s current reliance on surveillance capitalism and its arbitrary (not to mention unfair) blue check mark solution are good examples.

Bitcoin took a different approach. It allowed anyone to do anything, including participating in consensus, but required those who did the most important work to incur an upfront cost. This was a positive form of self-censorship: Anyone could be a miner, but they had to prove honest intent by spending money.

This proof-of-work (PoW) approach to building Sybil resistance has succeeded, at least for a payment system. The Bitcoin platform is paradoxically both the most open and most secure platform on the internet. Tellingly, PoW was originally invented in the 1990s to fight spam email.

Musk’s proposed subscription model for Twitter is philosophically similar.

Users who pay a monthly fee are less likely to be bots or click farms, so the rest of the network can trust them more — similar to how Bitcoin nodes defer to miners who’ve done the most “work.”

Most popular social networks worldwide as of January 2022 ranked by number of monthly active users (in millions). Source: Statista

If the Twitter algorithm also prioritizes comments and retweets from subscribers, then curation can also improve — similar to how proof-of-stake (PoS) systems often appoint one validator to propose a new block and empower a committee of other validators to double-check their work. All else being equal, a tweet from a paying subscriber that’s liked and retweeted by other paying subscribers is more likely to be useful.

People who complain that this approach discriminates against the poor misunderstand how social media already works. A lot of creators are already paying to get more traction. They just do it in the black market. Why else would there be so many ways to buy influence? So many fake accounts don’t happen by accident. Charging people directly has more integrity because we’ll know exactly who is paying.

Paying subscribers also allows Twitter to diversify away from ad revenues, throttling down the surveillance capitalism. Today, users who don’t pay to buy influence still pay with their attention, which the algorithms constantly try to hijack with polarizing content to sell more ads. Subscription models tend to lead to content that prioritizes quality over quantity, thus the success of Substack and Netflix.

Musk has also hinted at open-sourcing the search algorithm and someday paying content creators. These features would bring the Bitcoin analogy full circle. If Twitter lets anyone pay for a subscription, then redirects a portion of those revenues to the most popular creators and curators, it will better align incentives between content creators and consumers. In Bitcoin, the greediest miner is forced to become the most honest one. Twitter should work the same way.

To be clear, a centralized platform owned by private investors is still a far cry from a fully decentralized network like Bitcoin. But the idea of introducing a cost to doing the most important work, then rewarding those who do a good job is arguably the most important contribution crypto has made to society. We should applaud any attempt to port these ideas over to existing platforms, however limited they might be.

Someday we’ll hopefully have fully decentralized social media. Until then, we can use a better Twitter.

Omid Malekan is a nine-year veteran of the crypto industry and an adjunct professor at Columbia Business School, where he lectures on blockchain and crypto. He is the author of the upcoming book Re-Architecting Trust: The Curse of History and the Crypto Cure for Money, Markets, and Platforms.

This article is for general information purposes and is not intended to be and should not be taken as legal or investment advice. The views, thoughts, and opinions expressed here are the author’s alone and do not necessarily reflect or represent the views and opinions of Cointelegraph.

";bp.audio="https://s3.cointelegraph.com/audio/96805.920f4501-9717-42a0-85a1-e17521d5e189.mp3";bp.facebookShares=58;bp.twitterShares=j;bp.linkedinShares=j;bp.redditShares=G;bp.views=6645;bp.shares=64;bp.tags=[{id:bq,slug:ar,title:as,url:"/tags/twitter"},{id:"712",slug:"technology",title:"Technology",url:"/tags/technology"},{id:"895",slug:"tech",title:"Tech",url:"/tags/tech"},{id:"1299",slug:"adoption",title:br,url:aK},{id:"2090",slug:"silicon-valley",title:"Silicon Valley",url:"/tags/silicon-valley"},{id:"7146",slug:"social-media",title:"Social Media",url:"/tags/social-media"},{id:"9307",slug:"elon-musk",title:"Elon Musk",url:"/tags/elon-musk"},{id:"9362",slug:"tech-analysis",title:"Tech Analysis",url:"/tags/tech-analysis"}];bp.topics=[];bp.relatedPosts=[{id:"86800",isSponsored:a,isPressRelease:a,isExplained:a,isMagazinePost:a,url:"/explained/what-is-total-value-locked-tvl-in-crypto-and-why-does-it-matter",absoluteUrl:"https://cointelegraph.com/explained/what-is-total-value-locked-tvl-in-crypto-and-why-does-it-matter",title:"What is total value locked (TVL) in crypto and why does it matter?",cover:"https://s3.cointelegraph.com/storage/uploads/view/a43548cc2dbd83257552bd26eeb422f6.jpg",datePublished:b,dateHuman:b,publishedDateTimeObject:e,categorySlug:c,categoryUrl:aa,categoryName:c,authorName:"Emi Lacapra",authorUrl:"/authors/emi-lacapra",previewText:c,badgeSlug:c,badgeName:c,views:j,showShares:d,showStats:d},{id:"97116",isSponsored:a,isPressRelease:a,isExplained:a,isMagazinePost:a,url:"/news/developers-could-have-prevented-crypto-s-2022-hacks-if-they-took-basic-security-measures",absoluteUrl:"https://cointelegraph.com/news/developers-could-have-prevented-crypto-s-2022-hacks-if-they-took-basic-security-measures",title:"Developers could have prevented crypto's 2022 hacks if they took basic security measures",cover:"https://s3.cointelegraph.com/uploads/2022-11/fddcf7d8-1712-424f-8cb0-e38b8572076e.jpg",datePublished:b,dateHuman:b,publishedDateTimeObject:e,categorySlug:c,categoryUrl:aa,categoryName:c,authorName:"Stephen Lloyd Webber",authorUrl:"/authors/stephen-lloyd-webber",previewText:c,badgeSlug:c,badgeName:c,views:j,showShares:d,showStats:d},{id:"97207",isSponsored:a,isPressRelease:a,isExplained:a,isMagazinePost:a,url:"/news/can-we-move-on-from-ftx-s-collapse-now-and-get-back-to-the-basics",absoluteUrl:"https://cointelegraph.com/news/can-we-move-on-from-ftx-s-collapse-now-and-get-back-to-the-basics",title:"Let’s move on from FTX’s collapse and get back to the basics",cover:"https://s3.cointelegraph.com/uploads/2022-11/dc4e5930-48df-45d0-9048-9fd2b21f1199.jpg",datePublished:b,dateHuman:b,publishedDateTimeObject:e,categorySlug:c,categoryUrl:aa,categoryName:c,authorName:"Pat White",authorUrl:"/authors/pat-white",previewText:c,badgeSlug:c,badgeName:c,views:j,showShares:d,showStats:d},{id:"96313",isSponsored:a,isPressRelease:a,isExplained:a,isMagazinePost:a,url:"/news/twitter-monetization-and-free-speech-drove-binance-s-500m-injection-cz",absoluteUrl:"https://cointelegraph.com/news/twitter-monetization-and-free-speech-drove-binance-s-500m-injection-cz",title:"Twitter monetization and free speech drove Binance’s $500M injection: CZ",cover:"https://s3.cointelegraph.com/uploads/2022-11/9a804e4f-a54d-4dc6-b086-32f9dfdf4183.jpg",datePublished:b,dateHuman:b,publishedDateTimeObject:e,categorySlug:c,categoryUrl:aa,categoryName:c,authorName:bs,authorUrl:bt,previewText:c,badgeSlug:c,badgeName:c,views:j,showShares:d,showStats:d},{id:"96614",isSponsored:a,isPressRelease:a,isExplained:a,isMagazinePost:a,url:"/news/here-s-why-binance-s-cz-invested-in-twitter-following-elon-musk-acquisition",absoluteUrl:"https://cointelegraph.com/news/here-s-why-binance-s-cz-invested-in-twitter-following-elon-musk-acquisition",title:"Here’s why Binance’s CZ invested in Twitter following Elon Musk acquisition",cover:"https://s3.cointelegraph.com/uploads/2022-11/fb0f66b5-74bd-4da8-94a6-bca1896c6705.jpg",datePublished:b,dateHuman:b,publishedDateTimeObject:e,categorySlug:c,categoryUrl:aa,categoryName:c,authorName:" Arijit Sarkar ",authorUrl:"/authors/arijit-sarkar",previewText:c,badgeSlug:c,badgeName:c,views:j,showShares:d,showStats:d},{id:"96705",isSponsored:a,isPressRelease:a,isExplained:a,isMagazinePost:a,url:"/news/what-musk-s-twitter-acquisition-could-mean-for-social-media-crypto-adoption",absoluteUrl:"https://cointelegraph.com/news/what-musk-s-twitter-acquisition-could-mean-for-social-media-crypto-adoption",title:"What Musk’s Twitter acquisition could mean for social media crypto adoption",cover:"https://s3.cointelegraph.com/uploads/2022-11/b7c3900b-2320-4425-bc46-c6f776f384e1.jpg",datePublished:b,dateHuman:b,publishedDateTimeObject:e,categorySlug:c,categoryUrl:aa,categoryName:c,authorName:" Prashant Jha ",authorUrl:"/authors/prashant-jha",previewText:c,badgeSlug:c,badgeName:c,views:j,showShares:d,showStats:d}];bp.trackingPixelUrl="https://zoa.cointelegraph.com/pixel?postId=96805®ionId=1";bp.showShares=d;bp.showStats=d;bp.isNoIndex=a;bu.cacheKey="en.LanguageType.1";bu.id=bv;bu.short=at;bu.domain=bw;bu.code=at;bu.articleId=ai;bx.cacheKey="en.LanguageType.2";bx.id=by;bx.short=au;bx.domain=bz;bx.code=au;bx.articleId=ai;bA.cacheKey="en.LanguageType.6";bA.id=bB;bA.short=av;bA.domain=bC;bA.code=av;bA.articleId=ai;bD[0]={id:"526",type:h,isImage:a,isHtml:a,isWidget:a,isSidePromoButton:a,isStretch:a,isAdbutler:d,isAdbutlerYoutube:a,isPromoButton:a,isPromoButtonStack:a,isSticky:a,isMagazinePost:a,place:bo,url:b,base64:b,image:e,title:bE,comment:bE,priority:g,weight:bF,code:" if (!window.AdButler){(function(){var s = document.createElement("script"); s.async = true; s.type = "text/javascript";s.src = 'https://servedbyadbutler.com/app.js';var n = document.getElementsByTagName("script")[0]; n.parentNode.insertBefore(s, n);}());} var AdButler = AdButler || {}; AdButler.ads = AdButler.ads || []; var abkw = window.abkw || ''; var plc352960 = window.plc352960 || 0; document.write(''; AdButler.ads.push({handler: function(opt){ AdButler.register(169476, 352960, [728,90], 'placement_352960_'+opt.place, opt); }, opt: { place: plc352960++, keywords: abkw, domain: 'servedbyadbutler.com', click:'CLICK_MACRO_PLACEHOLDER' }}); ",options:{},trackingPixelUrl:b,youtubeVideoId:b,adbutlerDataUrl:"https://servedbyadbutler.com/adserve/;ID=169476;setID=352960;type=json;ip=18.237.200.182",widgetType:b,stretchType:b,promoButtonType:b,promoButtonUrl:b,postData:e,userIpAddress:i,adbutlerZoneId:e};bG.id=bv;bG.url="https://cointelegraph.com";bG.name="English";bG.domain=bw;bG.timezone="Europe/London";bG.short=at;bG.code=at;bG.emailSubscribes=[D,E];bG.robotsTxt="User-Agent: * Disallow: /embed/post-sidebar/ Disallow: /embed/post-recomend/ Disallow: /adbutler Disallow: /marketcap Disallow: /exchange Disallow: /ico-calendar Disallow: /search?query=* Disallow: /search Disallow: /profile Allow: /magazine/wp-content Allow: /magazine/wp-admin/admin-ajax.php Allow: /magazine/wp-includes/js Disallow: /magazine/wp-login.php Disallow: /magazine/wp-register.php Disallow: /magazine/xmlrpc.php Disallow: /magazine/template.html Disallow: /magazine/wp-admin Disallow: /magazine/wp-includes Disallow: /magazine/archive Disallow: /magazine/?s= Sitemap: https://cointelegraph.com/sitemap.xml ";bG.isHidden=a;bG.position=n;return {layout:"default",data:[{currentMeta:bm,currentArticle:bp,currentAlternates:[bu,bx,bA],metas:[bm],articles:[bp],infiniteArticles:[],infiniteArticlesAmount:j,infiniteArticlesOffset:j,infiniteAlternates:[bu,bx,bA,[]],bannersOptions:bD}],fetch:{},error:e,state:{currentLanguage:bG,languages:[{id:bB,url:"https://fr.cointelegraph.com",name:"Français",domain:bC,timezone:"Europe/Paris",short:av,code:av,emailSubscribes:[D,E],robotsTxt:"User-Agent: * Disallow: /marketcap Disallow: /embed/post-sidebar/ Disallow: /embed/post-recomend/ Disallow: /category/quiz Disallow: /lightning-network-101 Disallow: /search?query=* Disallow: /search",isHidden:a,position:-1},{id:"17",url:"https://ar.cointelegraph.com",name:"عربي (Arabic)",domain:"ar.cointelegraph.com",timezone:"Asia/Dubai",short:bH,code:bH,emailSubscribes:[D,E],robotsTxt:"User-Agent: * Disallow: /franchise Disallow: /marketcap Disallow: /ico-101 Disallow: /embed/post-sidebar/ Disallow: /embed/post-recomend/ Disallow: /lightning-network-101 Disallow: /category/quiz Disallow: /search?query=* Disallow: /search Sitemap: https://ar.cointelegraph.com/sitemap.xml",isHidden:a,position:j},{id:"4",url:"https://cointelegraphcn.com",name:"简体 (Chinese)",domain:"cointelegraphcn.com",timezone:"Asia/Hong_Kong",short:"cn",code:"zh",emailSubscribes:[D,E],robotsTxt:"User-agent: * Allow: / Disallow: /search?query=* Disallow: /search Sitemap: https://cointelegraphcn.com/sitemap.xml",isHidden:a,position:g},{id:"5",url:"https://de.cointelegraph.com",name:"Deutsch",domain:"de.cointelegraph.com",timezone:"Europe/Berlin",short:bI,code:bI,emailSubscribes:[D,E],robotsTxt:"User-Agent: * Disallow: /submit-a-post Disallow: /marketcap Disallow: /embed/post-sidebar/ Disallow: /embed/post-recomend/ Disallow: /category/quiz Disallow: /lightning-network-101 Disallow: /search?query=* Disallow: /search Sitemap: https://de.cointelegraph.com/sitemap.xml",isHidden:a,position:k},bG,{id:by,url:"https://es.cointelegraph.com",name:"Español",domain:bz,timezone:"Europe/Madrid",short:au,code:au,emailSubscribes:[D,E],robotsTxt:"User-Agent: * Disallow: /marketcap Disallow: /embed/post-sidebar/ Disallow: /embed/post-recomend/ Disallow: /category/quiz Disallow: /lightning-network-101 Disallow: /search?query=* Disallow: /search Sitemap: https://es.cointelegraph.com/sitemap.xml",isHidden:a,position:t},{id:"7",url:"https://it.cointelegraph.com",name:"Italiano",domain:"it.cointelegraph.com",timezone:"Europe/Lisbon",short:bJ,code:bJ,emailSubscribes:[D,E],robotsTxt:"User-Agent: * Disallow: /submit-a-post Disallow: /exchange Disallow: /marketcap Disallow: /events Disallow: /ico-101 Disallow: /ico-calendar Disallow: /embed/post-sidebar/ Disallow: /embed/post-recomend/ Disallow: /ripple-101 Disallow: /lightning-network-101 Disallow: /category/quiz Disallow: /search?query=* Disallow: /search Sitemap: https://it.cointelegraph.com/sitemap.xml",isHidden:a,position:y},{id:"22",url:"https://jp.cointelegraph.com",name:"日本語 (Japanese)",domain:"jp.cointelegraph.com",timezone:"Asia/Tokyo",short:"jp",code:"ja",emailSubscribes:[D,E],robotsTxt:"User-Agent: * Disallow: /franchise Disallow: /marketcap Disallow: /ico-101 Disallow: /embed/post-sidebar/ Disallow: /embed/post-recomend/ Disallow: /ripple-101 Disallow: /bitcoin-for-beginners Disallow: /ethereum-for-beginners Disallow: /bitcoin-cash-for-beginners Disallow: /lightning-network-101 Disallow: /category/quiz Disallow: /search?query=* Disallow: /search Sitemap: https://jp.cointelegraph.com/sitemap.xml",isHidden:a,position:G},{id:"26",url:"https://kr.cointelegraph.com",name:"한국어 (Korean)",domain:"kr.cointelegraph.com",timezone:"Asia/Seoul",short:"kr",code:"ko",emailSubscribes:[D,E],robotsTxt:"User-agent: * Allow: / Disallow: /search?query=* Disallow: /search Sitemap: https://kr.cointelegraph.com/sitemap.xml",isHidden:a,position:ab},{id:"23",url:"https://cointelegraph.com.br",name:"Português brasileiro",domain:"cointelegraph.com.br",timezone:"America/Manaus",short:"br",code:"pt-BR",emailSubscribes:[D,E],robotsTxt:"User-Agent: * Disallow: /marketcap Disallow: /embed/post-sidebar/ Disallow: /embed/post-recomend/ Disallow: /ripple-101 Disallow: /category/quiz Disallow: /lightning-network-101 Disallow: /search?query=* Sitemap: https://cointelegraph.com.br/sitemap.xml",isHidden:a,position:Q},{id:"27",url:"https://tr.cointelegraph.com",name:"Türkçe",domain:"tr.cointelegraph.com",timezone:"Europe/Istanbul",short:bK,code:bK,emailSubscribes:[D,E],robotsTxt:"User-agent: * Allow: / Disallow: /search?query=* Disallow: /search Sitemap: https://tr.cointelegraph.com/sitemap.xml",isHidden:a,position:ac}],editorsPosts:[{id:"97216",isSponsored:a,isPressRelease:a,isExplained:a,isMagazinePost:a,url:"/news/ftx-collapse-could-see-crypto-sector-layoffs-accelerate",absoluteUrl:"https://cointelegraph.com/news/ftx-collapse-could-see-crypto-sector-layoffs-accelerate",title:"FTX collapse could see crypto sector layoffs accelerate",cover:"https://s3.cointelegraph.com/uploads/2022-11/24214bf9-e51a-49d4-9d33-7d9e8aec1682.jpg",datePublished:aj,dateHuman:"17 hours ago",publishedDateTimeObject:{year:C,month:v,day:K,hour:y,minute:54,second:bL,millisecond:j},categorySlug:L,categoryUrl:M,categoryName:N,authorName:bs,authorUrl:bt,previewText:c,badgeSlug:c,badgeName:c,views:j,showShares:d,showStats:d},{id:"97212",isSponsored:a,isPressRelease:a,isExplained:a,isMagazinePost:a,url:"/news/apple-job-listings-and-patents-hint-at-foray-into-3d-mixed-reality-world",absoluteUrl:"https://cointelegraph.com/news/apple-job-listings-and-patents-hint-at-foray-into-3d-mixed-reality-world",title:"Apple job listings and patents hint at foray into ‘3D mixed-reality world’ ",cover:"https://s3.cointelegraph.com/uploads/2022-11/f182a194-ccbc-42ae-876b-25f02ea4a071.jpg",datePublished:aj,dateHuman:"19 hours ago",publishedDateTimeObject:{year:C,month:v,day:K,hour:t,minute:k,second:32,millisecond:j},categorySlug:L,categoryUrl:M,categoryName:N,authorName:aL,authorUrl:aM,previewText:c,badgeSlug:c,badgeName:c,views:j,showShares:d,showStats:d},{id:"97209",isSponsored:a,isPressRelease:a,isExplained:a,isMagazinePost:a,url:"/news/bitcoin-buyers-drawn-by-rising-prices-not-dislike-for-banks-bis-report",absoluteUrl:"https://cointelegraph.com/news/bitcoin-buyers-drawn-by-rising-prices-not-dislike-for-banks-bis-report",title:"Bitcoin buyers drawn by rising prices, not dislike for banks: BIS report ",cover:"https://s3.cointelegraph.com/uploads/2022-11/a525cbfe-001a-42d6-820a-e1cc6e28447f.jpg",datePublished:aj,dateHuman:"21 hours ago",publishedDateTimeObject:{year:C,month:v,day:K,hour:k,minute:k,second:18,millisecond:j},categorySlug:L,categoryUrl:M,categoryName:N,authorName:aL,authorUrl:aM,previewText:c,badgeSlug:c,badgeName:c,views:j,showShares:d,showStats:d},{id:"97205",isSponsored:a,isPressRelease:a,isExplained:a,isMagazinePost:a,url:"/news/charities-risk-losing-a-generation-of-donors-if-they-don-t-accept-crypto",absoluteUrl:"https://cointelegraph.com/news/charities-risk-losing-a-generation-of-donors-if-they-don-t-accept-crypto",title:"Charities risk losing a generation of donors if they don’t accept crypto",cover:"https://s3.cointelegraph.com/uploads/2022-11/5c7b2205-1e12-4a90-b5fc-a68597fce56a.jpg",datePublished:"2022-11-14",dateHuman:"Nov 14, 2022",publishedDateTimeObject:{year:C,month:v,day:bM,hour:aw,minute:Q,second:41,millisecond:j},categorySlug:L,categoryUrl:M,categoryName:N,authorName:"Ciaran Lyons",authorUrl:"/authors/ciaran-lyons",previewText:c,badgeSlug:c,badgeName:c,views:j,showShares:d,showStats:d},{id:"97215",isSponsored:a,isPressRelease:a,isExplained:a,isMagazinePost:a,url:"/news/nifty-news-nike-unveils-nft-platform-steve-jobs-sandals-sell-for-200k-and-more",absoluteUrl:"https://cointelegraph.com/news/nifty-news-nike-unveils-nft-platform-steve-jobs-sandals-sell-for-200k-and-more",title:"Nifty News: Nike unveils NFT platform, Steve Jobs’ sandals sell for $200K and more ",cover:"https://s3.cointelegraph.com/uploads/2022-11/360bd32b-9593-4fa0-8c33-03f343144536.jpg",datePublished:aj,dateHuman:"18 hours ago",publishedDateTimeObject:{year:C,month:v,day:K,hour:y,minute:F,second:37,millisecond:j},categorySlug:L,categoryUrl:M,categoryName:N,authorName:" Stephen Katte ",authorUrl:"/authors/stephen-katte",previewText:c,badgeSlug:c,badgeName:c,views:j,showShares:d,showStats:d}],hotPosts:[{id:"97086",isSponsored:a,isPressRelease:a,isExplained:a,isMagazinePost:a,url:"/news/sam-bankman-fried-is-under-supervision-in-bahamas-looking-to-flee-to-dubai",absoluteUrl:"https://cointelegraph.com/news/sam-bankman-fried-is-under-supervision-in-bahamas-looking-to-flee-to-dubai",title:"Sam Bankman-Fried is ‘under supervision’ in Bahamas, looking to flee to Dubai",cover:"https://s3.cointelegraph.com/uploads/2022-11/d38cd36f-a01d-4f07-8e20-9a90c2b86932.jpg",datePublished:"2022-11-12",dateHuman:"Nov 12, 2022",publishedDateTimeObject:{year:C,month:v,day:ad,hour:aw,minute:$,second:35,millisecond:j},categorySlug:L,categoryUrl:M,categoryName:N,authorName:" Felix Ng ",authorUrl:"/authors/felix-ng",previewText:c,badgeSlug:c,badgeName:c,views:173826,showShares:d,showStats:d},{id:"93908",isSponsored:a,isPressRelease:a,isExplained:a,isMagazinePost:a,url:"/news/why-is-the-crypto-market-down-today",absoluteUrl:"https://cointelegraph.com/news/why-is-the-crypto-market-down-today",title:"Why is the crypto market down today?",cover:"https://s3.cointelegraph.com/uploads/2022-09/8032812d-1d50-46ab-b965-a0cb6dd41a63.JPG",datePublished:"2022-11-09",dateHuman:"Nov 09, 2022",publishedDateTimeObject:{year:C,month:v,day:ac,hour:ax,minute:n,second:46,millisecond:j},categorySlug:L,categoryUrl:M,categoryName:N,authorName:" Ray Salmond ",authorUrl:"/authors/ray-salmond",previewText:c,badgeSlug:c,badgeName:c,views:83835,showShares:d,showStats:d},{id:"96916",isSponsored:a,isPressRelease:a,isExplained:a,isMagazinePost:a,url:"/news/ledger-hardware-wallets-hit-by-the-ftx-earthquake-cto-says",absoluteUrl:"https://cointelegraph.com/news/ledger-hardware-wallets-hit-by-the-ftx-earthquake-cto-says",title:"Ledger hardware wallets hit by the FTX earthquake — CTO",cover:"https://s3.cointelegraph.com/uploads/2022-11/29c335c3-f3da-4ab7-8db3-b6aa48827e11.jpg",datePublished:bN,dateHuman:bO,publishedDateTimeObject:{year:C,month:v,day:A,hour:A,minute:36,second:40,millisecond:j},categorySlug:L,categoryUrl:M,categoryName:N,authorName:"Helen Partz",authorUrl:"/authors/helen-partz",previewText:c,badgeSlug:c,badgeName:c,views:70577,showShares:d,showStats:d},{id:"96895",isSponsored:a,isPressRelease:a,isExplained:a,isMagazinePost:a,url:"/news/ftx-and-binance-s-ongoing-saga-everything-that-s-happened-until-now",absoluteUrl:"https://cointelegraph.com/news/ftx-and-binance-s-ongoing-saga-everything-that-s-happened-until-now",title:"FTX’s ongoing saga: Everything that’s happened until now",cover:"https://s3.cointelegraph.com/uploads/2022-11/2f0cdf81-6520-4d3a-951c-5eafc09e440c.jpg",datePublished:bN,dateHuman:bO,publishedDateTimeObject:{year:C,month:v,day:A,hour:t,minute:G,second:57,millisecond:j},categorySlug:L,categoryUrl:M,categoryName:N,authorName:aL,authorUrl:aM,previewText:c,badgeSlug:c,badgeName:c,views:48240,showShares:d,showStats:d},{id:"95997",isSponsored:a,isPressRelease:a,isExplained:a,isMagazinePost:a,url:"/news/why-is-the-crypto-market-up-today",absoluteUrl:"https://cointelegraph.com/news/why-is-the-crypto-market-up-today",title:"Why is the crypto market up today?",cover:"https://s3.cointelegraph.com/uploads/2022-10/a633230d-3f9a-4749-8bab-017c4b9435a0.jpg",datePublished:aj,dateHuman:"4 hours ago",publishedDateTimeObject:{year:C,month:v,day:K,hour:19,minute:bL,second:45,millisecond:j},categorySlug:"market-analysis",categoryUrl:aN,categoryName:aO,authorName:" Kyle White ",authorUrl:"/authors/kyle-white",previewText:c,badgeSlug:c,badgeName:c,views:36996,showShares:d,showStats:d}],countryCode:"US",isAdblockDetected:d,preferredLanguage:e,isYoutubeApiReady:a,now:1668556211050,i18n:{by:"by",backToTop:"Back to top",blockNewsTitle:"Latest news",postsLoadMore:"Load more articles",postsLoading:"Loading",magazinePostAuthor:aP,error403Text:"Sorry, but your account is blocked.",error404Text:"

Sorry, the page you are looking for has not been found.

Try checking the URL for errors and hit refresh button in your browser.

",error500Text:"

Internal Server Error

",errorGoBackButtonCap:"Go back",errorGoBackButtonUrl:bP,errorArticleTitlePrefix:"Article titled",errorArticleTitlePostfix:"was previously available by this link.",errorArticleDesc:"

Cointelegraph has made the decision to remove this article due to its lack of compliance with our standards of journalistic quality and integrity.

We apologize for this error, and our editorial team will do its best to maintain the standards to which we hold ourselves.

",headerLogoTitle:bQ,headerLogoSlogan:"The future of money",submitPressReleaseCap:"Submit press release",careersCap:bR,careersUrl:bS,advertiseCap:bT,advertiseUrl:"/advertise",searchButtonCap:"Search",appBannerAndroidText:"Install the Cointelegraph app from the Play Store",appBannerAndroidBtn:"Download",appBannerAndroidUrl:"https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=cointelegraph.com",appBannerIosName:bU,appBannerIosDeveloper:bQ,appBannerIosText:"GET — On the App Store",appBannerIosAction:"View",appBannerIosUrl:bV,profileLogIn:"Sign In",profileCap:"Profile",profileEditProfile:"Edit Profile",profileLogOut:"Sign Out",aboutUsText:"Cointelegraph covers fintech, blockchain and Bitcoin bringing you the latest news and analyses on the future of money.",footerIcpText:"footer.icp.text",companyDetails:"about.us.operator",termsOfServicesText:"Terms of services and Privacy policy",menuBadgeNew:"new",footerNewsletter:"COINTELEGRAPH NEWSLETTER",footerFollowUs:"FOLLOW US",footerMobileApp:"MOBILE APPS",menuBadgeSoon:"soon",menuBadgePartner:"Partner",subscribeButtonCap:ae,subscribeEmailLabel:"Email",subscribeSuccess:bW,subscribeError:bX,privacyPolicyCap:"Accept",privacyPolicyText:"Cointelegraph.com uses Cookies to ensure the best experience for you.",priceIndexesPageTitle:bY,journalistJoinUs:"Are you a journalist or an editor?",journalistJoinUs2:"Join us",journalistJoinUsEmail:"career@cointelegraph.com",androidAppAlt:"Cointelegraph Android App",androidAppTitle:"Android",androidAppUrlDesktop:aQ,androidAppUrlMobile:aQ,androidAppChinaUrl:"https://s3.cointelegraph.com/crypto-app-cn.apk",iosAppAlt:"Cointelegraph iOS App",iosAppTitle:"App Store",iosAppUrlDesktop:bZ,iosAppUrlMobile:bV,iosAppChinaUrl:"https://apps.apple.com/cn/app/id1498770434",qrCodeChina:"https://s3.cointelegraph.com/storage/uploads/view/04aea5eb4b16e5e760765b5cfe686add.svg",editorsChoice:"Editor's choice",hotStories:"Hot stories",pressReleases:b_,flashNews:"index.goto.flashnews.btn.label",loadMore:"Load more",hideItems:"Hide",stretchSubscribeTo:"Subscribe to our channel",stretchWatchNow:ae,stretchSponsored:"stretch_banners.sponsored.badge",promoButtonNexoCap:"Buy Crypto & Get 0.5% Back",promoButtonNexoText:l,promoButtonNexoUrlMainDesktop:"nexo.btn.desktop.index.url",promoButtonNexoUrlMainMobile:"nexo.btn.mobile.index.url",promoButtonNexoUrlTagDesktop:"nexo.btn.desktop.tag-page.url",promoButtonNexoUrlTagMobile:"nexo.btn.mobile.tag-page.url",promoButtonNexoUrlCategoryDesktop:"nexo.btn.desktop.category-page.url",promoButtonNexoUrlCategoryMobile:"nexo.btn.mobile.category-page.url",promoButtonNexoUrlSidebar:"nexo.btn.sidebar.url",promoButtonNexoUrlArticleMobile:"nexo.btn.mobile.article.url",promoButtonCryptoCap:"Get Crypto At True Cost",promoButtonCryptoText:"Cryptoassets are complex instruments and investments carry a high risk of losing value. You should educate yourself in how crypto-markets work before making any investments. Always invest responsibly and be prepared for the risks associated with investing in or using cryptoassets. This promotion cannot be considered investment advice.",promoButtonCryptoUrlMainDesktop:"crypto.btn.desktop.index.url",promoButtonCryptoUrlMainMobile:aR,promoButtonCryptoUrlTagDesktop:"crypto.btn.desktop.tag-page.url",promoButtonCryptoUrlTagMobile:aR,promoButtonCryptoUrlCategoryDesktop:"crypto.btn.desktop.category-page.url",promoButtonCryptoUrlCategoryMobile:"crypto.btn.mobile.category-page.url",promoButtonCryptoUrlSidebar:"crypto.btn.sidebar.url",promoButtonCryptoUrlArticleMobile:aR,promoButtonEtoroCap:b$,promoButtonEtoroText:"Cryptoasset investing is unregulated in some EU countries. No consumer protection. Your capital is at risk.",promoButtonEtoroUrlMainDesktop:"etoro.btn.desktop.index.url",promoButtonEtoroUrlMainMobile:"etoro.btn.mobile.index.url",promoButtonEtoroUrlTagDesktop:"etoro.btn.desktop.tag-page.url",promoButtonEtoroUrlTagMobile:"etoro.btn.mobile.tag-page.url",promoButtonEtoroUrlCategoryDesktop:"etoro.btn.desktop.category-page.url",promoButtonEtoroUrlCategoryMobile:"etoro.btn.mobile.category-page.url",promoButtonEtoroUrlSidebar:"etoro.btn.sidebar.url",promoButtonEtoroUrlArticleMobile:"etoro.btn.mobile.article.url",promoButtonEtoro2Cap:"Invest Now and Get $10",promoButtonEtoro2Text:"eToro USA LLC; Investments are subject to market risk, including the possible loss of principal.",promoButtonEtoro2UrlMainDesktop:"etoro2.btn.desktop.index.url",promoButtonEtoro2UrlMainMobile:"etoro2.btn.mobile.index.url",promoButtonEtoro2UrlTagDesktop:"etoro2.btn.desktop.tag-page.url",promoButtonEtoro2UrlTagMobile:"etoro2.btn.mobile.tag-page.url",promoButtonEtoro2UrlCategoryDesktop:"etoro2.btn.desktop.category-page.url",promoButtonEtoro2UrlCategoryMobile:"etoro2.btn.mobile.category-page.url",promoButtonEtoro2UrlSidebar:"etoro2.btn.sidebar.url",promoButtonEtoro2UrlArticleMobile:"etoro2.btn.mobile.article.url",promoButtonEtoro3Cap:b$,promoButtonEtoro3Text:"Cryptoassets are highly volatile and unregulated in the UK. No consumer protection. Tax on profits may apply.",promoButtonEtoro3UrlMainDesktop:"etoro3.btn.desktop.index.url",promoButtonEtoro3UrlMainMobile:"etoro3.btn.mobile.index.url",promoButtonEtoro3UrlTagDesktop:"etoro3.btn.desktop.tag-page.url",promoButtonEtoro3UrlTagMobile:"etoro3.btn.mobile.tag-page.url",promoButtonEtoro3UrlCategoryDesktop:"etoro3.btn.desktop.category-page.url",promoButtonEtoro3UrlCategoryMobile:"etoro3.btn.mobile.category-page.url",promoButtonEtoro3UrlSidebar:"etoro3.btn.sidebar.url",promoButtonEtoro3UrlArticleMobile:"etoro3.btn.mobile.article.url",promoButtonHitbtcCap:"Robust liquidity on HitBTC",promoButtonHitbtcText:l,promoButtonHitbtcUrlMainDesktop:"hitbtc.btn.desktop.index.url",promoButtonHitbtcUrlMainMobile:ak,promoButtonHitbtcUrlTagDesktop:ak,promoButtonHitbtcUrlTagMobile:ak,promoButtonHitbtcUrlCategoryDesktop:"hitbtc.btn.desktop.category-page.url",promoButtonHitbtcUrlCategoryMobile:"hitbtc.btn.mobile.category-page.url",promoButtonHitbtcUrlSidebar:ak,promoButtonHitbtcUrlArticleMobile:ak,promoButtonChangellyCap:"fast exchange on Changelly",promoButtonChangellyText:"This is to note that you should realize all crypto trading risks. Please make sure that you understand how crypto exchange service works.",promoButtonChangellyUrlMainDesktop:"changelly.btn.desktop.index.url",promoButtonChangellyUrlMainMobile:al,promoButtonChangellyUrlTagDesktop:al,promoButtonChangellyUrlTagMobile:al,promoButtonChangellyUrlCategoryDesktop:"changelly.btn.desktop.category-page.url",promoButtonChangellyUrlCategoryMobile:"changelly.btn.mobile.category-page.url",promoButtonChangellyUrlSidebar:al,promoButtonChangellyUrlArticleMobile:al,promoButtonTokenboxCap:"Manage your assets",promoButtonTokenboxText:ay,promoButtonTokenboxUrlMainDesktop:"tokenbox.btn.desktop.index.url",promoButtonTokenboxUrlMainMobile:am,promoButtonTokenboxUrlTagDesktop:am,promoButtonTokenboxUrlTagMobile:am,promoButtonTokenboxUrlCategoryDesktop:"tokenbox.btn.desktop.category-page.url",promoButtonTokenboxUrlCategoryMobile:"tokenbox.btn.mobile.category-page.url",promoButtonTokenboxUrlSidebar:am,promoButtonTokenboxUrlArticleMobile:am,promoButtonBinanceCap:"Crypto Marketplace",promoButtonBinanceText:"Сryptoassets are considered very high risk, speculative purchases and investing in them may carry a high risk of losing money. You should educate yourself on how crypto markets work before making any investments. Always invest responsibly and be prepared for the risks associated with investing in or using crypto assets.",promoButtonBinanceUrlMainDesktop:"binance.btn.desktop.index.url",promoButtonBinanceUrlMainMobile:"binance.btn.mobile.index.url",promoButtonBinanceUrlTagDesktop:"binance.btn.desktop.tag-page.url",promoButtonBinanceUrlTagMobile:"binance.btn.mobile.tag-page.url",promoButtonBinanceUrlCategoryDesktop:"binance.btn.desktop.category-page.url",promoButtonBinanceUrlCategoryMobile:"binance.btn.mobile.category-page.url",promoButtonBinanceUrlSidebar:"binance.btn.sidebar.url",promoButtonBinanceUrlArticleMobile:"binance.btn.mobile.article.url",promoButtonLedgerCap:"40% off hardware wallet",promoButtonLedgerText:ay,promoButtonLedgerUrlMainDesktop:"ledger.btn.desktop.index.url",promoButtonLedgerUrlMainMobile:"ledger.btn.mobile.index.url",promoButtonLedgerUrlTagDesktop:"ledger.btn.desktop.tag-page.url",promoButtonLedgerUrlTagMobile:"ledger.btn.mobile.tag-page.url",promoButtonLedgerUrlCategoryDesktop:"ledger.btn.desktop.category-page.url",promoButtonLedgerUrlCategoryMobile:"ledger.btn.mobile.category-page.url",promoButtonLedgerUrlSidebar:"ledger.btn.sidebar.url",promoButtonLedgerUrlArticleMobile:"ledger.btn.mobile.article.url",promoButtonOkexCap:"One-stop crypto exchange",promoButtonOkexText:ay,promoButtonOkexUrlMainDesktop:"okex.btn.desktop.index.url",promoButtonOkexUrlMainMobile:"okex.btn.mobile.index.url",promoButtonOkexUrlTagDesktop:"okex.btn.desktop.tag-page.url",promoButtonOkexUrlTagMobile:"okex.btn.mobile.tag-page.url",promoButtonOkexUrlCategoryDesktop:"okex.btn.desktop.category-page.url",promoButtonOkexUrlCategoryMobile:"okex.btn.mobile.category-page.url",promoButtonOkexUrlSidebar:"okex.btn.sidebar.url",promoButtonOkexUrlArticleMobile:"okex.btn.mobile.article.url",promoButtonSyncbondCap:"DEFI CRYPTOBOND ",promoButtonSyncbondText:ay,promoButtonSyncbondUrlMainDesktop:"syncbond.btn.desktop.index.url",promoButtonSyncbondUrlMainMobile:"syncbond.btn.mobile.index.url",promoButtonSyncbondUrlTagDesktop:"syncbond.btn.desktop.tag-page.url",promoButtonSyncbondUrlTagMobile:"syncbond.btn.mobile.tag-page.url",promoButtonSyncbondUrlCategoryDesktop:"syncbond.btn.desktop.category-page.url",promoButtonSyncbondUrlCategoryMobile:"syncbond.btn.mobile.category-page.url",promoButtonSyncbondUrlSidebar:"syncbond.btn.sidebar.url",promoButtonSyncbondUrlArticleMobile:"syncbond.btn.mobile.article.url",promoButtonBybitCap:"Claim up to 3,500 BIT",promoButtonBybitText:l,promoButtonBybitUrlMainDesktop:"bybit.btn.desktop.index.url",promoButtonBybitUrlMainMobile:"bybit.btn.mobile.index.url",promoButtonBybitUrlTagDesktop:"bybit.btn.desktop.tag-page.url",promoButtonBybitUrlTagMobile:"bybit.btn.mobile.tag-page.url",promoButtonBybitUrlCategoryDesktop:"bybit.btn.desktop.category-page.url",promoButtonBybitUrlCategoryMobile:"bybit.btn.mobile.category-page.url",promoButtonBybitUrlSidebar:"bybit.btn.sidebar.url",promoButtonBybitUrlArticleMobile:"bybit.btn.mobile.article.url",promoButtonBybit2Cap:"Join Bybit",promoButtonBybit2Text:l,promoButtonBybit2UrlMainDesktop:"bybit2.btn.desktop.index.url",promoButtonBybit2UrlMainMobile:"bybit2.btn.mobile.index.url",promoButtonBybit2UrlTagDesktop:"bybit2.btn.desktop.tag-page.url",promoButtonBybit2UrlTagMobile:"bybit2.btn.mobile.tag-page.url",promoButtonBybit2UrlCategoryDesktop:"bybit2.btn.desktop.category-page.url",promoButtonBybit2UrlCategoryMobile:"bybit2.btn.mobile.category-page.url",promoButtonBybit2UrlSidebar:"bybit2.btn.sidebar.url",promoButtonBybit2UrlArticleMobile:"bybit2.btn.mobile.article.url",promoButtonCoinappCap:"EXPLORE WITH COIN!",promoButtonCoinappText:l,promoButtonCoinappUrlMainDesktop:"coinapp.btn.desktop.index.url",promoButtonCoinappUrlMainMobile:"coinapp.btn.mobile.index.url",promoButtonCoinappUrlTagDesktop:"coinapp.btn.desktop.tag-page.url",promoButtonCoinappUrlTagMobile:"coinapp.btn.mobile.tag-page.url",promoButtonCoinappUrlCategoryDesktop:"coinapp.btn.desktop.category-page.url",promoButtonCoinappUrlCategoryMobile:"coinapp.btn.mobile.category-page.url",promoButtonCoinappUrlSidebar:"coinapp.btn.sidebar.url",promoButtonCoinappUrlArticleMobile:"coinapp.btn.mobile.article.url",promoButtonNbcCap:"Crypto in your super",promoButtonNbcText:l,promoButtonNbcUrlMainDesktop:"nbc.btn.desktop.index.url",promoButtonNbcUrlMainMobile:"nbc.btn.mobile.index.url",promoButtonNbcUrlTagDesktop:"nbc.btn.desktop.tag-page.url",promoButtonNbcUrlTagMobile:"nbc.btn.mobile.tag-page.url",promoButtonNbcUrlCategoryDesktop:"nbc.btn.desktop.category-page.url",promoButtonNbcUrlCategoryMobile:"nbc.btn.mobile.category-page.url",promoButtonNbcUrlSidebar:"nbc.btn.sidebar.url",promoButtonNbcUrlArticleMobile:"nbc.btn.mobile.article.url",promoButtonExodusCap:"Join the Exodus",promoButtonExodusText:l,promoButtonExodusUrlMainDesktop:"exodus.btn.desktop.index.url",promoButtonExodusUrlMainMobile:"exodus.btn.mobile.index.url",promoButtonExodusUrlTagDesktop:"exodus.btn.desktop.tag-page.url",promoButtonExodusUrlTagMobile:"exodus.btn.mobile.tag-page.url",promoButtonExodusUrlCategoryDesktop:"exodus.btn.desktop.category-page.url",promoButtonExodusUrlCategoryMobile:"exodus.btn.mobile.category-page.url",promoButtonExodusUrlSidebar:"exodus.btn.sidebar.url",promoButtonExodusUrlArticleMobile:"exodus.btn.mobile.article.url",promoButtonCoinsmartCap:"Got CAD? → CoinSmart",promoButtonCoinsmartText:l,promoButtonCoinsmartUrlMainDesktop:"coinsmart.btn.desktop.index.url",promoButtonCoinsmartUrlMainMobile:"coinsmart.btn.mobile.index.url",promoButtonCoinsmartUrlTagDesktop:"coinsmart.btn.desktop.tag-page.url",promoButtonCoinsmartUrlTagMobile:"coinsmart.btn.mobile.tag-page.url",promoButtonCoinsmartUrlCategoryDesktop:"coinsmart.btn.desktop.category-page.url",promoButtonCoinsmartUrlCategoryMobile:"coinsmart.btn.mobile.category-page.url",promoButtonCoinsmartUrlSidebar:"coinsmart.btn.sidebar.url",promoButtonCoinsmartUrlArticleMobile:"coinsmart.btn.mobile.article.url",promoButtonAmlCap:"Is your crypto legit? (AML)",promoButtonAmlText:l,promoButtonAmlUrlMainDesktop:"aml.btn.desktop.index.url",promoButtonAmlUrlMainMobile:"aml.btn.mobile.index.url",promoButtonAmlUrlTagDesktop:"aml.btn.desktop.tag-page.url",promoButtonAmlUrlTagMobile:"aml.btn.mobile.tag-page.url",promoButtonAmlUrlCategoryDesktop:"aml.btn.desktop.category-page.url",promoButtonAmlUrlCategoryMobile:"aml.btn.mobile.category-page.url",promoButtonAmlUrlSidebar:"aml.btn.sidebar.url",promoButtonAmlUrlArticleMobile:"aml.btn.mobile.article.url",promoButtonCoinsquareCap:"CANADIAN EXCHANGE",promoButtonCoinsquareText:l,promoButtonCoinsquareUrlMainDesktop:"coinsquare.btn.desktop.index.url",promoButtonCoinsquareUrlMainMobile:"coinsquare.btn.mobile.index.url",promoButtonCoinsquareUrlTagDesktop:"coinsquare.btn.desktop.tag-page.url",promoButtonCoinsquareUrlTagMobile:"coinsquare.btn.mobile.tag-page.url",promoButtonCoinsquareUrlCategoryDesktop:"coinsquare.btn.desktop.category-page.url",promoButtonCoinsquareUrlCategoryMobile:"coinsquare.btn.mobile.category-page.url",promoButtonCoinsquareUrlSidebar:"coinsquare.btn.sidebar.url",promoButtonCoinsquareUrlArticleMobile:"coinsquare.btn.mobile.article.url",promoButtonStoicCap:"NO TIME TO TRADE? AUTOMATE!",promoButtonStoicText:l,promoButtonStoicUrlMainDesktop:"stoic.btn.desktop.index.url",promoButtonStoicUrlMainMobile:"stoic.btn.mobile.index.url",promoButtonStoicUrlTagDesktop:"stoic.btn.desktop.tag-page.url",promoButtonStoicUrlTagMobile:"stoic.btn.mobile.tag-page.url",promoButtonStoicUrlCategoryDesktop:"stoic.btn.desktop.category-page.url",promoButtonStoicUrlCategoryMobile:"stoic.btn.mobile.category-page.url",promoButtonStoicUrlSidebar:"stoic.btn.sidebar.url",promoButtonStoicUrlArticleMobile:"stoic.btn.mobile.article.url",promoButtonCoinloanCap:"GET CRYPTO LOAN",promoButtonCoinloanText:l,promoButtonCoinloanUrlMainDesktop:"coinloan.btn.desktop.index.url",promoButtonCoinloanUrlMainMobile:"coinloan.btn.mobile.index.url",promoButtonCoinloanUrlTagDesktop:"coinloan.btn.desktop.tag-page.url",promoButtonCoinloanUrlTagMobile:"coinloan.btn.mobile.tag-page.url",promoButtonCoinloanUrlCategoryDesktop:"coinloan.btn.desktop.category-page.url",promoButtonCoinloanUrlCategoryMobile:"coinloan.btn.mobile.category-page.url",promoButtonCoinloanUrlSidebar:"coinloan.btn.sidebar.url",promoButtonCoinloanUrlArticleMobile:"coinloan.btn.mobile.article.url",promoButtonCryptoComCap:"Earn up to 14.5% p.a.",promoButtonCryptoComText:l,promoButtonCryptoComUrlMainDesktop:"crypto-com.btn.desktop.index.url",promoButtonCryptoComUrlMainMobile:"crypto-com.btn.mobile.index.url",promoButtonCryptoComUrlTagDesktop:"crypto-com.btn.desktop.tag-page.url",promoButtonCryptoComUrlTagMobile:"crypto-com.btn.mobile.tag-page.url",promoButtonCryptoComUrlCategoryDesktop:"crypto-com.btn.desktop.category-page.url",promoButtonCryptoComUrlCategoryMobile:"crypto-com.btn.mobile.category-page.url",promoButtonCryptoComUrlSidebar:"crypto-com.btn.sidebar.url",promoButtonCryptoComUrlArticleMobile:"crypto-com.btn.mobile.article.url",promoButtonCoinbaseCap:"Join Coinbase today",promoButtonCoinbaseText:l,promoButtonCoinbaseUrlMainDesktop:"coinbase.btn.desktop.index.url",promoButtonCoinbaseUrlMainMobile:"coinbase.btn.mobile.index.url",promoButtonCoinbaseUrlTagDesktop:"coinbase.btn.desktop.tag-page.url",promoButtonCoinbaseUrlTagMobile:"coinbase.btn.mobile.tag-page.url",promoButtonCoinbaseUrlCategoryDesktop:"coinbase.btn.desktop.category-page.url",promoButtonCoinbaseUrlCategoryMobile:"coinbase.btn.mobile.category-page.url",promoButtonCoinbaseUrlSidebar:"coinbase.btn.sidebar.url",promoButtonCoinbaseUrlArticleMobile:"coinbase.btn.mobile.article.url",promoButtonNebeusCap:"Discover Crypto-Renting",promoButtonNebeusText:l,promoButtonNebeusUrlMainDesktop:"nebeus.btn.desktop.index.url",promoButtonNebeusUrlMainMobile:"nebeus.btn.mobile.index.url",promoButtonNebeusUrlTagDesktop:"nebeus.btn.desktop.tag-page.url",promoButtonNebeusUrlTagMobile:"nebeus.btn.mobile.tag-page.url",promoButtonNebeusUrlCategoryDesktop:"nebeus.btn.desktop.category-page.url",promoButtonNebeusUrlCategoryMobile:"nebeus.btn.mobile.category-page.url",promoButtonNebeusUrlSidebar:"https://nebeus.com?utm_source=Ad_Cointelegraph&utm_medium=Ad_Cointelegraph&utm_campaign=Ad_Cointelegraph&utm_id=Ad_Cointelegraph&utm_term=Ad_Cointelegraph&utm_content=Ad_Cointelegraph",promoButtonNebeusUrlArticleMobile:"nebeus.btn.mobile.article.url",promoButtonKucoinCap:"Claim $500 Bonus",promoButtonKucoinText:l,promoButtonKucoinUrlMainDesktop:"kucoin.btn.desktop.index.url",promoButtonKucoinUrlMainMobile:"kucoin.btn.mobile.index.url",promoButtonKucoinUrlTagDesktop:"kucoin.btn.desktop.tag-page.url",promoButtonKucoinUrlTagMobile:"kucoin.btn.mobile.tag-page.url",promoButtonKucoinUrlCategoryDesktop:"kucoin.btn.desktop.category-page.url",promoButtonKucoinUrlCategoryMobile:"kucoin.btn.mobile.category-page.url",promoButtonKucoinUrlSidebar:"kucoin.btn.sidebar.url",promoButtonKucoinUrlArticleMobile:"kucoin.btn.mobile.article.url",promoButtonCrescentCap:"Exchange now on Hybrid DEX",promoButtonCrescentText:l,promoButtonCrescentUrlMainDesktop:"crescent.btn.desktop.index.url",promoButtonCrescentUrlMainMobile:"crescent.btn.mobile.index.url",promoButtonCrescentUrlTagDesktop:"crescent.btn.desktop.tag-page.url",promoButtonCrescentUrlTagMobile:"crescent.btn.mobile.tag-page.url",promoButtonCrescentUrlCategoryDesktop:"crescent.btn.desktop.category-page.url",promoButtonCrescentUrlCategoryMobile:"crescent.btn.mobile.category-page.url",promoButtonCrescentUrlSidebar:"crescent.btn.sidebar.url",promoButtonCrescentUrlArticleMobile:"crescent.btn.mobile.article.url",promoButtonUpholdCap:"Trade Now on Uphold",promoButtonUpholdText:l,promoButtonUpholdUrlMainDesktop:"uphold.btn.desktop.index.url",promoButtonUpholdUrlMainMobile:"uphold.btn.mobile.index.url",promoButtonUpholdUrlTagDesktop:"uphold.btn.desktop.tag-page.url",promoButtonUpholdUrlTagMobile:"uphold.btn.mobile.tag-page.url",promoButtonUpholdUrlCategoryDesktop:"uphold.btn.desktop.category-page.url",promoButtonUpholdUrlCategoryMobile:"uphold.btn.mobile.category-page.url",promoButtonUpholdUrlSidebar:"uphold.btn.sidebar.url",promoButtonUpholdUrlArticleMobile:"uphold.btn.mobile.article.url",promoButtonXgoCap:"EARN APY ON TRADES WITH XGO",promoButtonXgoText:l,promoButtonXgoUrlMainDesktop:"xgo.btn.desktop.index.url",promoButtonXgoUrlMainMobile:"xgo.btn.mobile.index.url",promoButtonXgoUrlTagDesktop:"xgo.btn.desktop.tag-page.url",promoButtonXgoUrlTagMobile:"xgo.btn.mobile.tag-page.url",promoButtonXgoUrlCategoryDesktop:"xgo.btn.desktop.category-page.url",promoButtonXgoUrlCategoryMobile:"xgo.btn.mobile.category-page.url",promoButtonXgoUrlSidebar:"xgo.btn.sidebar.url",promoButtonXgoUrlArticleMobile:"xgo.btn.mobile.article.url",promoButtonBitgetCap:"20 USDT zu gewinnen",promoButtonBitgetText:"Bitte beachten Sie, dass Sie die angegebenen Handelsstrategien auf eigene Gefahr nutzen. Wir möchten Sie bitten, dass Sie sich im Voraus gründlich über Kryptowährungen und deren Handel informieren.",promoButtonBitgetUrlMainDesktop:"bitget.btn.desktop.index.url",promoButtonBitgetUrlMainMobile:"bitget.btn.mobile.index.url",promoButtonBitgetUrlTagDesktop:"bitget.btn.desktop.tag-page.url",promoButtonBitgetUrlTagMobile:"bitget.btn.mobile.tag-page.url",promoButtonBitgetUrlCategoryDesktop:"bitget.btn.desktop.category-page.url",promoButtonBitgetUrlCategoryMobile:"bitget.btn.mobile.category-page.url",promoButtonBitgetUrlSidebar:"bitget.btn.sidebar.url",promoButtonBitgetUrlArticleMobile:"bitget.btn.mobile.article.url",promoButtonsGroupDisclaimer:"Crypto assets are a high-risk investment. You should consider whether you understand the possibility of losing money due to leverage. None of the material should be considered as investment advice!",editorChoiceTitle:"Editor’s Choice",advertiseLinkLabel:"Advertise with us",advertiseLinkUrl:ca,newsSubscriberEmail:cb,newsSubscriberSubscribe:ae,newsSubscriberLabel:"Today's news, in your inbox",newsSubscriberTitle:"Cointelegraph Digest",newsSubscriberSubtitle:"Your daily news digest, in the mail",newsSubscriberSend:ae,newsSubscriberPlaceholder:"Email address",newsSubscriberError:bX,newsSubscriberSuccess:bW,newsSubscriberThankYou:"Thank you!",newsSubscriberSuccessDescription:"You should confirm the subscription in your inbox",newsSubscriberDaily:"Daily",newsSubscriberWeekly:"Weekly",youtubeBannerChannelUrl:"https://www.youtube.com/user/cointelegraph",youtubeBannerHeadline:"Cointelegraph YouTube",youtubeBannerButtonLabel:ae,tagTitleAltPostfix:aS,tagMoreCap:"Show more",tagLessCap:"Show less",tagRecent:"Recent",tagTop:"Top News",youSearchedFor:"Search results for:",searchTitle:"Search the site",searchNothingFound:"Nothing found. We didn't find any result for",searching:"Searching...",pressRelease:"Press release",socialClipboardLabel:"Link copied",socialWechatHeaderText:cc,socialWechatFooterText:cc,socialWechatFooterError:"WeChat error",articleMoreAboutTopic:"article.more_about_topic",articleRelatedNewsTitle:"Related News",articleDisclaimerPaid:"This publication is sponsored.",articleDisclaimerDesc:"Cointelegraph does not endorse and is not responsible for or liable for any content, accuracy, quality, advertising, products, or other materials on this page. Readers should do their own research before taking any actions related to the company. Cointelegraph is not responsible, directly or indirectly, for any damage or loss caused or alleged to be caused by or in connection with the use of or reliance on any content, goods, or services mentioned in the press release.",articleListenTo:"Listen to article",articleTotalShares:"Total shares",articleTotalViews:"Total views",blockshowPromoText:"blockshow.promo.text",mimicBlock:"mimic.block.under.article",postTitleSeoTail:"post.title.seo-tail",postLiveDataViewMore:"View More",softwareApplicationName:bU,softwareApplicationIosUrl:bZ,softwareApplicationAndroidUrl:aQ,indexSubscriptionsBannerTitle:"The Latest from Cointelegraph",indexSubscriptionsBannerButtonLabel:"Subscribe to what you like",newsletterPageTitle:"Cointelegraph Newsletters",newsletterPageDescription:"Select the Cointelegraph newsletters to which you would like to subscribe to receive the latest news and analysis directly from our team.",newsletterPagePopupDetailsEnter:"Enter your email to subscribe",newsletterPagePopupDetailsMore:"Select more or enter your email to subscribe",newsletterPageMarketsOutlookTitle:"Markets Outlook",newsletterPageMarketsOutlookSubheading:af,newsletterPageMarketsOutlookDescription:"Weekly newsletter that covers the main factors influencing Bitcoin’s price and the week ahead.",newsletterPageAltcoinRoundupTitle:"Crypto Market Musings",newsletterPageAltcoinRoundupSubheading:cd,newsletterPageAltcoinRoundupDescription:"Ahead-of-the-curve analysis that tracks emerging trends in the crypto market.",newsletterPageDeFiNewsletterTitle:"DeFi Newsletter",newsletterPageDeFiNewsletterSubheading:cd,newsletterPageDeFiNewsletterDescription:"A weekly summary of the most impactful DeFi stories, insights and education developments.",newsletterPageMagazineNewsletterTitle:"Magazine Newsletter",newsletterPageMagazineNewsletterSubheading:"Delivered on Tuesdays every two weeks",newsletterPageMagazineNewsletterDescription:"In-depth and incisive features on cryptocurrency, blockchain and NFTs every other week. ",newsletterPageLawDecodedTitle:"Law Decoded",newsletterPageLawDecodedSubheading:af,newsletterPageLawDecodedDescription:"A weekly summary of the latest news in crypto legislation and regulations.",newsletterPageNiftyNewsletterTitle:"Nifty Newsletter",newsletterPageNiftyNewsletterSubheading:ce,newsletterPageNiftyNewsletterDescription:"A weekly summary of the latest NFT headlines.",newsletterPageOneMinuteLetterTitle:"1 Minute Letter",newsletterPageOneMinuteLetterSubheading:af,newsletterPageOneMinuteLetterDescription:"A daily selection of the best crypto news.",newsletterPageConsultingNewsletterTitle:"CT Consulting Biweekly Report",newsletterPageConsultingNewsletterSubheading:"Delivered on Wednesdays every two weeks",newsletterPageConsultingNewsletterDescription:"In-depth Market Insights report from our Research team.",newsletterPageCryptoBizNewsletterTitle:"Crypto Biz Newsletter",newsletterPageCryptoBizNewsletterSubheading:af,newsletterPageCryptoBizNewsletterDescription:"A weekly pulse of the business behind blockchain and crypto.",newsletterPageWeekInReviewTitle:"A week in review",newsletterPageWeekInReviewSubheading:"Delivered every Sunday",newsletterPageWeekInReviewDescription:"A weekly digest of what happened in the crypto space.",inArticleSubscriptionFormInputPlaceholder:cb,inArticleSubscriptionFormTos:"By subscribing, you agree to our Terms of Services and Privacy Policy",inArticleSubscriptionFormBtnLabel:ae,inArticleSubscriptionFormEmailErrorMsg:"Please enter a valid email address",inArticleSubscriptionFormSuccessMsg:"Thank you for subscribing",inArticleSubscriptionFormMarketsOutlookDelivery:af,inArticleSubscriptionFormLawDecodedDelivery:af,inArticleSubscriptionFormDefiNewsletterDelivery:"DELIVERED EVERY FRIDAY",inArticleSubscriptionFormConsultingNewsletterDelivery:"delivered biweekly",inArticleSubscriptionFormCryptoBizDelivery:"Delivered every Thursday",inArticleSubscriptionFormNiftyNewsletterDelivery:ce,inArticleSubscriptionFormMagazineDelivery:"in.article.subscription.form.magazine.delivery",inArticleSubscriptionFormOneMinuteLetterDelivery:"in.article.subscription.form.one_minute_letter.delivery",inArticleSubscriptionFormWeekInReviewDelivery:"in.article.subscription.form.week_in_review.delivery",inArticleSubscriptionFormMarketsOutlookTitle:"Subscribe to the Markets Outlook newsletter",inArticleSubscriptionFormLawDecodedTitle:"Subscribe to the Law Decoded newsletter",inArticleSubscriptionFormDefiNewsletterTitle:"Subscribe to the Finance Redefined newsletter",inArticleSubscriptionFormConsultingNewsletterTitle:"Subscribe to the Cointelegraph Research Newsletter",inArticleSubscriptionFormCryptoBizTitle:"Subscribe to our Crypto Biz newsletter",inArticleSubscriptionFormNiftyNewsletterTitle:"Subscribe to the Nifty Newsletter",inArticleSubscriptionFormLawDecodedListId:"63518511686747533",inArticleSubscriptionFormMarketsOutlookListId:"63518681844418509",inArticleSubscriptionFormDefiNewsletterListId:"63518580167149221",inArticleSubscriptionFormConsultingNewsletterListId:"64408317476210640",inArticleSubscriptionFormCryptoBizListId:"63518622575756409",inArticleSubscriptionFormNiftyNewsletterListId:"63518610776131095",inArticleSubscriptionFormMagazineListId:"in.article.subscription.form.magazine.list-id",inArticleSubscriptionFormOneMinuteLetterListId:"in.article.subscription.form.one_minute_letter.list-id",inArticleSubscriptionFormWeekInReviewListId:"in.article.subscription.form.week_in_review.list-id",glossaryHeading:"Crypto Glossary",glossaryDesc:"If you’re new to the world of crypto, it’s easy to get lost in the sea of essential blockchain and cryptocurrency terms. Cointelegraph’s crypto glossary explains the major cryptocurrency terms you should know when learning about digital currencies. In this glossary, you will discover links to relevant articles and pages for crypto-related terms.",glossaryKeyboard:"You may also use your keyboard to move to the desired letter"},banners:{leaderboard_mobile:[{id:"236",type:h,isImage:a,isHtml:a,isWidget:a,isSidePromoButton:a,isStretch:a,isAdbutler:d,isAdbutlerYoutube:a,isPromoButton:a,isPromoButtonStack:a,isSticky:a,isMagazinePost:a,place:"leaderboard_mobile",url:b,base64:b,image:e,title:"Index Mobile",comment:"Index mobile banner",priority:j,weight:g,code:" if (!window.AdButler){(function(){var s = document.createElement("script"); s.async = true; s.type = "text/javascript";s.src = 'https://servedbyadbutler.com/app.js';var n = document.getElementsByTagName("script")[0]; n.parentNode.insertBefore(s, n);}());} var AdButler = AdButler || {}; AdButler.ads = AdButler.ads || []; var abkw = window.abkw || ''; var plc403005 = window.plc403005 || 0; document.write(''; AdButler.ads.push({handler: function(opt){ AdButler.register(169476, 403005, [728,90], 'placement_403005_'+opt.place, opt); }, opt: { place: plc403005++, keywords: abkw, domain: 'servedbyadbutler.com', click:'CLICK_MACRO_PLACEHOLDER' }}); ",options:{},trackingPixelUrl:b,youtubeVideoId:b,adbutlerDataUrl:"https://servedbyadbutler.com/adserve/;ID=169476;setID=403005;type=json;ip=18.237.200.182",widgetType:b,stretchType:b,promoButtonType:b,promoButtonUrl:b,postData:e,userIpAddress:i,adbutlerZoneId:e}],side:[{id:"469",type:an,isImage:a,isHtml:a,isWidget:d,isSidePromoButton:a,isStretch:a,isAdbutler:a,isAdbutlerYoutube:a,isPromoButton:a,isPromoButtonStack:a,isSticky:a,isMagazinePost:a,place:O,url:aT,base64:"ZWRpdG9ycy1jaG9pY2Utd2lkZ2V0",image:e,title:cf,comment:cf,priority:j,weight:g,code:b,options:{},trackingPixelUrl:e,youtubeVideoId:b,adbutlerDataUrl:b,widgetType:aT,stretchType:b,promoButtonType:aT,promoButtonUrl:b,postData:e,userIpAddress:i,adbutlerZoneId:e},{id:"334",type:aU,isImage:a,isHtml:d,isWidget:a,isSidePromoButton:a,isStretch:a,isAdbutler:a,isAdbutlerYoutube:a,isPromoButton:a,isPromoButtonStack:a,isSticky:a,isMagazinePost:a,place:O,url:cg,base64:ch,image:e,title:az,comment:az,priority:g,weight:g,code:"",options:[],trackingPixelUrl:b,youtubeVideoId:ci,adbutlerDataUrl:b,widgetType:b,stretchType:b,promoButtonType:b,promoButtonUrl:b,postData:e,userIpAddress:i,adbutlerZoneId:e},{id:"328",type:h,isImage:a,isHtml:a,isWidget:a,isSidePromoButton:a,isStretch:a,isAdbutler:d,isAdbutlerYoutube:a,isPromoButton:a,isPromoButtonStack:a,isSticky:a,isMagazinePost:a,place:O,url:b,base64:b,image:e,title:cj,comment:cj,priority:k,weight:g,code:" if (!window.AdButler){(function(){var s = document.createElement("script"); s.async = true; s.type = "text/javascript";s.src = 'https://servedbyadbutler.com/app.js';var n = document.getElementsByTagName("script")[0]; n.parentNode.insertBefore(s, n);}());} var AdButler = AdButler || {}; AdButler.ads = AdButler.ads || []; var abkw = window.abkw || ''; var plc351587 = window.plc351587 || 0; document.write(''; AdButler.ads.push({handler: function(opt){ AdButler.register(169476, 351587, [300,250], 'placement_351587_'+opt.place, opt); }, opt: { place: plc351587++, keywords: abkw, domain: 'servedbyadbutler.com', click:'CLICK_MACRO_PLACEHOLDER' }}); ",options:{},trackingPixelUrl:b,youtubeVideoId:b,adbutlerDataUrl:"https://servedbyadbutler.com/adserve/;ID=169476;setID=351587;type=json;ip=18.237.200.182",widgetType:b,stretchType:b,promoButtonType:b,promoButtonUrl:b,postData:e,userIpAddress:i,adbutlerZoneId:e},{id:"229",type:h,isImage:a,isHtml:a,isWidget:a,isSidePromoButton:a,isStretch:a,isAdbutler:d,isAdbutlerYoutube:a,isPromoButton:a,isPromoButtonStack:a,isSticky:a,isMagazinePost:a,place:O,url:b,base64:b,image:e,title:ck,comment:ck,priority:n,weight:g,code:" if (!window.AdButler){(function(){var s = document.createElement("script"); s.async = true; s.type = "text/javascript";s.src = 'https://servedbyadbutler.com/app.js';var n = document.getElementsByTagName("script")[0]; n.parentNode.insertBefore(s, n);}());} var AdButler = AdButler || {}; AdButler.ads = AdButler.ads || []; var abkw = window.abkw || ''; var plc351414 = window.plc351414 || 0; document.write(''; AdButler.ads.push({handler: function(opt){ AdButler.register(169476, 351414, [300,250], 'placement_351414_'+opt.place, opt); }, opt: { place: plc351414++, keywords: abkw, domain: 'servedbyadbutler.com', click:'CLICK_MACRO_PLACEHOLDER' }}); ",options:{},trackingPixelUrl:b,youtubeVideoId:b,adbutlerDataUrl:"https://servedbyadbutler.com/adserve/;ID=169476;setID=351414;type=json;ip=18

0 Response from Community